Those of you who are of a certain age likely had post-traumatic flashbacks when I dropped some Sister Souljah a couple of days back. In 1992 then-Arkansas governor Bill Clinton kicked his presidential campaign into high gear by putting Sister Souljah on blast over some comments she had made in the Washington Post. At a campaign appearance Clinton spoke thusly: “If you took the words ‘white’ and ‘black’ and reversed them, you might think David Duke was giving that speech.”
The original comment from the Washington Post: “I mean, if black people kill black people every day, why not have a week and kill white people?” No one in white America heard–or wanted to hear–her actual point: Why is it that one instance of a black person killing a white person should matter more than black people killing black people every day?
These comments came on the heels of Sister Souljah’s album 360 Degrees of Power, which came out in the aftermath of the Rodney King riots in Los Angeles. The album contains a provocative track (not that the rest of the album isn’t provocative–it is) entitled “Slavery’s Back in Effect”, which deals with the hypothetical of a future racist president reinstating slavery because black Americans are deemed not to have risen to an acceptable level of productivity, and is especially relevant today in Donald Trump’s America.
Clinton’s comments may have been true on the surface, yet they fail to take into account a reality which is as obvious as the nose on your face: 400 years of race-motivated violence and injustice perpetrated against black Americans by white supremacist America. This casts a pall over any claim of moral equivalence between antiracists and white supremacist segregationists.
White Americans: You do not get to police how black Americans respond to the pain of racial injustice. You do not get to police what constitutes an acceptable or an unacceptable response. Just shut up and listen.